[PDF][PDF] Evaluating Alternative Maintenance Strategies for Low-Volume Roads in Sub-Saharan Africa
C Cook - Transport Research Record, 1987 - onlinepubs.trb.org
C Cook
Transport Research Record, 1987•onlinepubs.trb.orgRecent applications ofthe World Bank's Highway Design and Maintenance (HDM) model in
sub-Saharan Africa indicate that periodic maintenance is generally justified by vehicle
operating cost savings only on paved roads with traffic levels of more than 100 vehicles per
day (vpd) and on unpaved roads with traffic levels of more than 50 vehicles per day. If traffic
levels are below 50 vpd on paved roads and 20 vpd on unpaved roads, the HD M indicates
that periodic maintenance should be postponed indefinitely. Road rehabilitation in …
sub-Saharan Africa indicate that periodic maintenance is generally justified by vehicle
operating cost savings only on paved roads with traffic levels of more than 100 vehicles per
day (vpd) and on unpaved roads with traffic levels of more than 50 vehicles per day. If traffic
levels are below 50 vpd on paved roads and 20 vpd on unpaved roads, the HD M indicates
that periodic maintenance should be postponed indefinitely. Road rehabilitation in …
Recent applications ofthe World Bank's Highway Design and Maintenance (HDM) model in sub-Saharan Africa indicate that periodic maintenance is generally justified by vehicle operating cost savings only on paved roads with traffic levels of more than 100 vehicles per day (vpd) and on unpaved roads with traffic levels of more than 50 vehicles per day. If traffic levels are below 50 vpd on paved roads and 20 vpd on unpaved roads, the HD M indicates that periodic maintenance should be postponed indefinitely. Road rehabilitation in potentially productive areas often appears economically justified at lower traffic volumes, based on the increase in agricultural production that occurs when road access is provided. These benefits may be lost if a rehabilitated road is allowed to deteriorate because of lack of maintenance. The potential loss of agricultural production is not considered in the HDM evaluation of an optimal road maintenance strategy. The relationship between road condition and agricultural productivity to develop an appropriate maintenance strategy for low-volume roads in sub-Saharan Africa is examined in this paper. Timely periodic maintenance is generally justified ifthe initial road construction investment was justified. If the expected increases in agricultural production or the related generated traffic is slow to materialize, the preferred economic strategy would be to defer periodic maintenance for 2 to 4 years. It is critical that roads be maintained routinely to preserve road access, which is the key to the effects of road investments on development.
The countries of sub-Saharan Africa share several characteristics that lead to low traffic volumes on most of their rural roads. Much of sub-Saharan Africa is still sparsely populated. This population is largely engaged in subsistence agriculture and often employs shifting cultivation, combined with or complemented by transhumant or nomadic herding. The modern transport needs associated with these traditional patterns of economic activity are minimal. The region is characterized by extremes of temperature and rainfall, which result in wide variations in vegetative cover and soil quality. Generally speaking, soils that are suitable for road building have relatively low agricultural potential, whereas soils with high agricultural potential are not well adapted for road construction and maintenance. The variations in climate also affect the choice of appropriate road maintenance strategies because, at low traffic volumes, climate is much more important than traffic in determining the rate of road deterioration. The traditional approach to development in sub-Saharan Africa has been to encourage the rural population to produce
onlinepubs.trb.org